Chinese School - Fighting the medical wolves in sheep's clothing

BIZCHINA / Weekly Roundup

Fighting the medical wolves in sheep's clothing

By Wang Ying (China Daily)
Updated: 2007-04-27 09:27

Angels in white robes! That may be a tautology, but that's the image of
doctors (and others in the medical profession) in China. In reality,
however, they are far removed from their traditional portrait. The thirst
for money has turned some of them into predators preying on patients.
They still have the white robes on, though, making them look more like
wolves in sheep's clothing (or the devil in angel's robes, if you will).

But are they alone to blame? Perhaps not! The hospitals and clinics they
work for are equally, if not more, responsible for the mess.

People buy medicines at a hospital pharmacy in Ningbo, East China's
Zhejiang Province. Many doctors prescribe unnecessary medicines to earn
extra money from companies making them. 

Starved of funds, some hospitals and doctors today rely on hongbao red
packets with kickbacks from patients and drug companies to fill their
pockets. One such patient is Zhang Nan's wife. Zhang, a retired teacher
in Nanjing, capital of East China's Jiangsu Province, had to give a
$5,000 hongbao to doctors and nurses of a Shanghai hospital last year to
ensure his wife got proper medical treatment. She was to undergo a brain
surgery.

The money, sent home by Zhang's son who works abroad, was shared among
"the doctor in charge, assistant doctors, the anesthesiologist and
nurses", www.xinhuanet.com quoted the retired teacher as having said.

"My wife received better treatment and recovered very well because I gave
the hongbao," he said, revealing that he learned the "trick" from an
unpleasant experience. His niece didn't get proper medical treatment when
doctors in Nanjing removed a stone from her gallbladder three years ago
because they didn't get their expected hongbao, he said. That has left
her with a long scar. They also prescribed a large number of unnecessary
medicines. And her medical charges were 2,000 yuan ($260) more than that
of patients who had given a hongbao of 1,000 yuan ($130) or more.

Though the health authorities have begun a campaign against unscrupulous
medical workers, the problem is too deep to be rooted out quickly or
easily. Ministry of Health (MOH) figures show that last year alone,
doctors and nurses in the country charged more than 240 million yuan ($31
million) in kickbacks.

Also last year, supervision and discipline inspection departments at all
levels in China began 2,535 bribery cases, involving 606 million yuan
($78.7 million), in the medical and pharmaceutical sectors, Beijing Youth
Daily has reported.

The fear of losing a loved one forces relatives to offer gifts (read
money) to doctors and nurses before an operation. Many doctors give
patients the cold shoulder till they get their "money".

Unfortunately such shady deals are not confined to the medical and
pharmaceutical circles. The education and agriculture sectors, too, have
been attacked by this plague.

At a national meeting aimed at eliminating unhealthy industrial practices
earlier this month, officials pledged to eliminate this disease.
Officials of the State Council's office, however, said that this year
they would focus on building professional ethics in the medical sector,
bringing down sky-high medicine prices and regulating the healthcare
market.

1 2 3 

(For more biz stories, please visit Industry Updates)

Learn Chinese, Chinese Online Class